top of page

The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Fish Bait You Never Knew About

Fishing is a timeless activity that combines relaxation with excitement. Whether you're an experienced angler or just starting, knowing which bait to use can make the difference between an excellent catch and a day of frustration. Many people understand that live bait or artificial lures are options, but selecting specific bait fish can be a mystery, especially for beginners. This guide will shine a light on the best fish to use as bait, ensuring a more successful and enjoyable time on the water!


Understanding the Fundamentals of Fishing Bait


To choose the right bait, start by understanding a few critical concepts. The best bait is the one that attracts your target fish. Different species have unique diets, and what works in one fishing spot may not work in another.


For example, when fishing in lakes for freshwater bass, smaller fish like shiners or chubs can lure larger predator fish into biting. Conversely, when saltwater fishing for tuna or marlin, larger baits such as mackerel or sardines are more effective. Knowing your target species and their habits will help you make informed decisions about your bait.


1. Nightcrawlers and Red Worms: A Classic Choice


Close-up of a well-worn fishing tackle box containing various baits, including worms.
A close-up of a fishing tackle box filled with various types of bait, focusing on nightcrawlers and red worms.

Worms are iconic bait that every angler should consider. Nightcrawlers and red worms are acclaimed for their effectiveness across a wide range of freshwater species, including trout, panfish, and bass.


These worms can be easily found at local stores and are relatively inexpensive. Their natural movement in water mimics prey, making them particularly appealing. For instance, using nightcrawlers has been shown to attract fish in around 70% of successful freshwater catches.


Be cautious, though. Before heading out, check your local regulations, as some areas restrict the use of live bait.


2. Minnows: A Favorite for Predatory Fish


If your goal is to catch game fish like walleye, pike, or bass, using small minnows can significantly boost your chances. Minnows are a staple in the diet of many larger fish and can be used live, dead, or as cut bait.


Anglers often choose live minnows for their natural movement, which can evoke predatory behavior. Depending on the season, minnows such as fatheads or shiners are usually available at bait shops. For example, fishing with fathead minnows can lead to a 50% increase in bites compared to using other baits.


Benefits of Using Minnows Include:


  1. Versatility: Can be fished using various techniques like under a bobber or on a jig.

  2. Attractive Scent: Their natural scent and movement entice more fish.


To maximize effectiveness, store minnows in a well-aerated container to keep them lively and appealing.


3. Shrimp: The Sea-Saver


Shrimp is unmatched in saltwater fishing and is a favorite for species like snapper, grouper, and flounder. They can be used fresh or frozen, either whole or cut into smaller pieces, depending on your target.


Shrimp has both scent and taste that attract fish. For example, snapper is known to bite shrimp about 60% of the time they encounter it. Shrimp are usually easy to find at local markets, making this bait readily accessible.


When fishing with shrimp, keep them cool and use an appropriate rig to ensure a natural presentation.


4. Crayfish: Treat for Freshwater Predators


Crayfish are an excellent choice for anglers aiming for larger freshwater fish like bass and catfish. They are particularly effective during warmer months when fish are foraging near shore.


You can use crayfish live or as cut bait. Bass often strike crayfish, leading to thrilling battles on the line. For example, while fishing with crayfish, enthusiasts can experience up to 30% more strikes.


Use crayfish effectively by fishing near rocks or structures where they naturally inhabit. Aim to mimic their movements to attract nearby predators.


5. Sardines: Powerhouses of Saltwater Fishing


Sardines are more than just a shelf staple; they are among the best baits for various sea fish, including mackerel, cobia, and tuna. Their oily and savory scent can attract fish from notable distances.


You can use sardines whole or in chunks. Many seasoned fishermen prefer sliced sardines because the oils released enhance their effectiveness considerably. Keeping sardines on ice helps maintain their freshness, which is vital for successful fishing.


6. Herring: A Top Choice for Bigger Fish


Herring is another versatile fish that works well in both fresh and saltwater fishing. This bait is particularly favored for larger species like striped bass and halibut.


Herring can be fished whole or cut into pieces for trolling. Their high oil content makes them attractive to predators. Studies show that fishing with herring can improve success rates by nearly 40% compared to standard bait fish.


When using herring, opt for a circle hook to secure your catch while minimizing injury, which increases the chances of a successful release.


7. Mackerel: A Fatty Delight


Mackerel is ideal for anglers targeting larger saltwater species such as tuna and shark. The high-fat content gives off a powerful scent, making them effective in deeper waters.


Fish with mackerel whole or in pieces. Target areas with underwater structures, since they tend to attract more predator fish. Freshly caught mackerel can significantly increase your chances of landing a big catch, making them a beloved option among serious anglers.


8. Eels: The Hardy Bait Option


Eels may not be as common, but they can be highly effective, especially for deep-sea fishing. They're ideal when targeting predator fish like catfish and strippers due to their natural movement and robust scent.


Eels can be fished whole or cut into sections. When using live eels, fishing near the bottom increases your chances of an encounter. Just be prepared for a more extended fight as fish like catfish can put up a serious struggle.


9. Artificial Bait: The New School


While natural bait is excellent, artificial bait has come a long way. Many modern lures mimic the movements and scents of real fish, making them a strong choice for anglers.


Options like soft plastics, jigs, and spoons can effectively draw in fish. When used correctly, they can mimic various marine creatures, providing versatility. The added benefit of artificial baits is their long-lasting nature, eliminating worries about bait dying before your fishing day ends.


Wrapping It Up


Choosing the right fish for bait may feel overwhelming at first, but it doesn't need to be complicated! By understanding your target species and selecting the best bait, you can significantly enhance your chances of catching that big fish.


Whether you prefer tried-and-true options like nightcrawlers or opt for durable artificial lures, fishing can be incredibly rewarding. Armed with this guide, you now know about some of the best fish bait that was once a mystery to you. So grab your tackle, choose your bait, and get ready to create unforgettable fishing memories. Happy fishing!

bottom of page