top of page

The Florida Keys Fisherman's Bible: Where to Reel 'Em In and How to Bring in the Big Ones

Writer: Flying FishmanFlying Fishman

Fishing in the Florida Keys is like stepping into a paradise where both sun and fish are abundant. Whether you are an experienced angler or a newcomer ready to cast your first line, the Keys offer a treasure trove of fishing opportunities. This guide explores the best fishing spots and techniques to help you make the most of your time in these vibrant waters.


Top Fishing Locations in the Florida Keys



Man holding a large sailfish on a boat under a clear sky. He's wearing sunglasses and gloves. The ocean is visible in the background.
Successful Catch In The Keys!


1. Key Largo


Key Largo, often known as the "Diving Capital of the World," is also a dream destination for anglers. The shallow flats and deep waters are home to species such as tarpon, bonefish, and snook.


Fishing around the islands in Florida Bay often yields impressive catches like redfish and mangrove snapper. Just a short distance from the Everglades National Park, you can experience the rich biodiversity here, ensuring an unforgettable fishing adventure. In fact, anglers have reported catching up to 20 fish in a single outing during peak seasons.


2. Islamorada


Islamorada, dubbed the "Sport Fishing Capital of the World," features some of the finest fishing charters around. The waters are teeming with species, including mahi-mahi, grouper, and swordfish.


Don’t miss the famous Alligator Reef, where you can target sailfish or indulge in deep-sea fishing with breathtaking vistas. The average catch weight for mahi-mahi here can range between 10 to 30 pounds, making each trip an exciting possibility.


3. Marathon


While Marathon may be quieter than its neighbors, it offers excellent fishing opportunities. This area features a mix of backcountry and offshore fishing spots.


Here, you can catch yellowtail snapper, barracuda, and kingfish. Anglers often rave about the chance to catch barracuda weighing close to 20 pounds, making this spot a hidden gem for fishing aficionados.


4. Big Pine Key


If you seek a unique experience, Big Pine Key is the place to fish among the mangroves. It's well-known for backcountry fishing along the flats, where you can target species like permit and tarpon.


The crystal-clear waters are perfect for paddleboarding or kayaking, allowing you to access lesser-known fishing areas. A guided tour can help you find prime spots, enhancing your chances of landing that trophy fish.


5. Key West


Key West is not only famous for its nightlife, but it is also a fishing hotspot. Here, you can enjoy deep-sea fishing, with marlin and tuna often on the line.


Don't overlook the nearby wrecks and reefs, as they host diseases like snapper and grouper. In fact, many anglers have reported successful catches exceeding 30 pounds in weight, making Key West a sought-after location for both experienced and novice fishermen.


Fishing Techniques for Various Species


1. Fly Fishing


Fly fishing in the Florida Keys is less just a technique; it is a way of life for many. The focus is on targeting species like tarpon and bonefish, using light tackle to present flies delicately on the water's surface.


This immersive method encourages anglers to engage with their surroundings, making every catch even more rewarding.


2. Light Tackle Fishing


Light tackle fishing is perfect for those wanting to catch smaller species like snapper and sea trout. Utilize lighter lines and smaller baits to increase your chances of landing fish, particularly in the backcountry waters.


This approach can lead to an enjoyable day on the water, with many anglers reporting catches of up to ten fish in a four-hour trip.


3. Deep-Sea Fishing


To target larger species like marlins and tunas, deep-sea fishing is the way to go. This method requires heavy tackle and is often done on charter boats that take you to the best spots.


The crew will provide guidance on the best bait and lures to use, ensuring you maximize your fishing experience. Many charters boast a success rate of over 75% for anglers hoping to land a big catch.


4. Bottom Fishing


Bottom fishing targets species that inhabit the reef or seabed. Using weighted rigs and natural baits like squid can lead to significant catches, including snapper and grouper.


When done right, anglers can fill their coolers with bounty from the deep, often encountering fish that weigh 10 pounds or more.


5. Night Fishing


Night fishing offers a thrilling alternative for catching species like tarpon and sharks. The night creates an entirely different atmosphere. Anglers often use glow sticks or underwater lights to attract fish, increasing their chances of a successful catch, particularly for species that are more active after dark.


Tips for Maximizing Your Catch in the Keys Waters


1. Know the Best Times to Fish


Timing is key in fishing. Early mornings and late afternoons usually provide the most productive times for catching fish. Many species are more active during these hours, significantly enhancing your chances of landing a catch.


2. Match the Hatch


Familiarizing yourself with the local bait can greatly increase your success. Using lures or baits that resemble the natural food in the water will help entice fish to your line.


3. Keep Your Cool


Patience is essential in fishing. The action may be slow at times, but staying focused and relaxed can lead to better results. Whenever possible, enjoy the scenery and take a deep breath to enjoy the moment.


4. Use Quality Gear


Investing in high-quality rods, reels, and tackle can dramatically enhance your fishing experience. Quality gear allows for better casting and can help ensure that you secure that big catch you’ve been dreaming about.


5. Be Respectful of the Ecosystem


While it may be tempting to keep every fish you catch, it's essential to be mindful of conservation and adhere to regulations to maintain the health of these waters for future generations. Practice catch and release where possible to help preserve the local ecosystem.


Unforgettable Adventures Await


The Florida Keys are home to some of the most incredible fishing experiences you could hope for. With diverse ecosystems and vibrant marine life, you will not only catch fish but also enjoy stunning views and a true connection to nature.


Whether you choose to fish in the bustling waters of Key West or the serene flats of Big Pine Key, you are sure to create unforgettable memories. Keep your gear ready, maintain patience, and respect the environment. Happy fishing!

bottom of page